Ethics In Giving

Ethics of Giving to the Poor
Peter Singer vs. Garrett Hardin

3/24/2009





Give a compassionate being a fish and hell eat for a daytime; teach a man to fish, and hell eat for a lifetime. This ancient Chinese power saw states the importance of not yet giving, but fate those in need to become self-sufficient in the future. The phrase stuck with me when meter reading Peter Singers and Garrett Hardins positions about helping the poor. I side with Singer that as a demonstrable and prosperous landed estate, we have a responsibility to take dole out of stack who argon less fortunate than us, but Hardin argues a very valid point; where do we draw the business organisation? When is it ethically justifiable to discontinue emboldening people or a nation and let them take care of themselves?
Singer begins his note with a very simple and logical statement that abject and death from lack of food, shelter, and medical care are bad. He then states that if it is in our power to prevent something bad from happening, without thereby sacrificing anything of comparable moral importance, we ought, morally to do it. I bank that Singer is not unreasonable for making such statements. A very common case we foresee today is people not helping financially.



Even though money is not nearly as important as a human life, and to ask to give a particular amount remote is not sacrificing anything of comparable moral importance. Singers only limitation to his entire position though is that we only bowdlerise ourselves to the level of marginal utility, which obviously means a greater sacrifice for those in higher positions. The problem I see with Singers view of marginal utility is that if we mechanically fix the needs of every person or nation at a certain period in time, the probability of those same people and nations needing aid in the future are extremely high, because since we only gave them a fish to eat that day, instead of teaching them how to fish by giving them aid and teaching them how to prosper and plan for...If you want to get a full essay, order it on our website: Orderessay



If you want to get a full essay, wisit our page: write my essay .